A charming British rom-com musical. An impossibly upbeat Brit meets a no-nonsense New Yorker when she picks him up from the airport for a family wedding. NYT Critic's Pick, named to Best of 2025 lists by USA Today and Entertainment Weekly.
“The sleeper hit of the season. Discovered it on TikTok and the chemistry between the two leads had the audience cheering from the first number.”A GUEST · 1,800 RESPONSES
I discovered this show on TikTok with the song New York and loved it instantly.
the sleeper hit of the season.
the chemistry between the two leads is electric.
ecstatic cheers at the start, mobbed stage door afterwards.
NYT Critic's Pick for good reason.
the 2hr 15min runtime feels a bit long for the story.
very small cast may feel underwhelming if you expect an ensemble.
leans into rom-com tropes—not for the cynical.
those wanting spectacle or large ensemble numbers. people who don't enjoy slow-burn romance. cynics who dislike rom-com conventions.
Eight Tony nominations have validated this modest British import as Broadway's answer to the question: can a small show survive? With a low weekly nut and TikTok traction for 'New York,' it's proving that intimacy and charm can compete in a season of spectacle—though spring grosses suggest it's settling into a comfortable niche rather than becoming the next breakout phenomenon.
RESEARCHED JULY 2026